My Photo
Name:
Location: Brisbane, Qld, Australia

A 50(ish) radio journalist and educator struggling for fitness after a lifetime of sloth.

Tuesday, May 16, 2006

Age of Consent - a moveable feast

Recently, the issue of Age of Consent came up in a forum where I hang around (http://www.calorieking.com.au/community/forums/Members-Chat/new-rule-for-relationships_dGhyZWFkX2lkPTcxMDY0.html) and I said I'd do a bit of research and see what the actual law says.

As I suspected, it's a bit complicated, but here goes.

In general terms, the age of consent, in most states, is 16 or 17 for both boys and girls ... and anyone having sex with a child under that age is committing a crime.

Here's a listing ...
State .. M-F....M-M....F-F
ACT ....16......16......16
NSW ...16 .....16.... 16
NT .......16 .....16 ....16
QLD ...16/18 18......16
SA ........17 .....17 ....17
TAS ......17 .....17 ....17
VIC .......16 .....16 ....16
WA .......16 ......16 ....16

The odd state out is Queensland, where the age of consent for male-male intercourse is 18, and where the age of consent for sodomy, even in a heterosexual relationship, is also 18.

However, there IS some leeway granted where the partner is of roughly the same age.

Tasmania appears to be the only state that has a legal provision on this - it says no crime is committed if the child was 15 or older and their partner was less than five years their senior, or if s/he was 12 or older and the partner was less than three years older.

My understanding, from talking to police in a variety of states, is that the same leeway applies unofficially pretty much everywhere.

So, if a child is (say) 13 and their boyfriend/girlfriend is 16, then no action is likely. If a child is 15 and their boyfriend/girlfriend is 20, then, again, no prosecution is likely.

If, however, the child is 13 and the boyfriend/girlfriend is 19 or 20 (or older), then a prosecution can, and in many cases will, be launched.

As an aside, the earlest reference to an age of sexual consent that I could find was in the United Kingdom, in 1275. It was originally 12, was raised to 13 in 1875 and to 16 in 1885 - and initially, it only referred to girls.

Now, as the thread outlined, there are calls for the law to be changed to make "relationship" illegal, if one partner is a teen, and the other is more than five years older.

What is really worrying about that call is that it is NOT talking just about sex (which, as you've read, is already covered by laws and practice around Australia) ... but about _all_ relationships.

It's suggesting that if a 21 year old buys his 16 year old girlfriend flowers, that should constitute an offence.

I gotta say, as the father of two, such a law would have made for a less stressful teenage years ... except that it would have been ignored - or worse, deliberately flouted.

And once we introduce laws that are made to be ignored, then we encourage our kids to ignore ALL laws. Which is not a precedent that I think is very wise.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home